Client Affairs Minister Alberto Garzón claimed in an interview with British newspaper The Guardian that mega-farms are damaging the setting and resulting in the export of poor-quality meat from the nation.
“What isn’t in any respect sustainable is these so-called mega-farms. They discover a village in a depopulated little bit of Spain and put in 4,000, or 5,000 or 10,000 head of cattle,” he instructed the newspaper.
“They pollute the soil, they pollute the water after which they export this poor-quality meat from these ill-treated animals”.
Since these feedback had been printed, there was an uproar about his feedback each throughout farmers’ unions and within the authorities.
A lot of what the minister has stated has been taken out of context and it’s necessary to level out that Garzón wasn’t speaking in regards to the high quality of Spanish meat basically, he was solely speaking in regards to the mass-produced meat from mega farms in sure areas.
READ ALSO – KEY STATS: What you could find out about Spain’s mega farms
There’s scientific proof proving that intensive livestock farming is damaging Spain’s setting and water provides, however is there any proof to recommend that it truly produces poor high quality meat too?
In keeping with Greenpeace Spain, the mega farm system all the time seeks the very best manufacturing of meat, milk and eggs on the lowest price and within the shortest attainable time, all to maximise earnings.
Which means that a lot of animals are crammed into confined areas somewhat than grazing or foraging outdoor, fed with low-cost feed imported from different international locations, and pumped stuffed with antibiotics and chemical compounds to assist them survive in these unsanitary residing circumstances.
The Native Spain has not discovered proof of any official research carried out in Spain which calls into query the standard of the meat because of intensive livestock farming.
Many of the worldwide reporting on meat high quality requirements is from animal rights teams who write that scientific research show manufacturing facility farming can result in the bacterial contamination of meat, corresponding to salmonella and E. coli, and might be breeding grounds for antibiotic-resistant micro organism.
However in keeping with Spain’s Agriculture Ministry, only one p.c of pig farms and three p.c of cow farms within the nation might be thought of massive scale, which means that many of the many various kinds of meat produced in Spain don’t come from these macrogranjas (as they’re known as in Spanish), though this doesn’t assure they don’t use an identical manufacturing mannequin.
In the event you take the instance of Spain’s jamón ibérico de bellota, high-quality cured ham from pigs ate up acorns in outside pastures, the rearing mannequin to acquire its beautiful style is totally the other of manufacturing facility farming.
What do The Native’s readers consider the standard of Spain’s meat?
Meat, whether or not cured or cooked, is an intrinsic a part of the every day eating regimen in Spain, so we determined to ask our readers what they actually thought in regards to the high quality of Spain’s meat and the way it compares to different international locations.
Half of our respondents (50.9 p.c) thought that Spanish meat wasn’t unhealthy high quality in any respect and really thought it was excellent in contrast with different international locations.
Readers Anna and Christopher agreed with the Spanish Prime Minister’s latest phrases when arguing that Spanish meat is of “wonderful high quality”.
Harriet additionally agreed, saying: “Spanish ham, pork merchandise, veal, and lamb are a few of the best meats on the earth! We go to Spain usually to eat!”.
Ann McKiernan additionally praised the standard of meat in Spain. She instructed The Native: “I’m proud of the standard, it compares favourably to meat I should purchase in different international locations. I’d favor extra availability of various cuts/thicknesses in supermarkets however typically, I can discover what I would like in butchers, even with my somewhat restricted Spanish”.
Jens Riis additionally couldn’t fault the standard of Spanish meat. “Right here in Madrid, we get wonderful meat: beef, pork, lamb; it’s nearly all the time prime drawer, by no means unhealthy,” she stated.
Jorge thought that Spain has a few of the finest meat in Europe with sustainable livestock, whereas Bruce thought that each the standard and worth are wonderful, and Daniel stated that “it’s actually tasty”.
Not everybody agreed nonetheless and round 1 / 4 of our respondents (24.6 p.c) stated that ‘sure’ Spanish meat is unhealthy. Lots of the solutions agreed with Garzón’s feedback in regards to the unhealthy high quality of meat from mega-farms, however a number of individuals additionally thought the style and the feel weren’t good both.
Maria thought that the animals in Spain usually are not fed high quality meals. “They need to be grass-fed and they don’t seem to be given correct residing requirements,” she stated. “In consequence, the meat doesn’t look or style nearly as good”.
Jane Pritchard instructed The Native: “The usual of beef and lamb is extraordinarily poor high quality and really costly, significantly lamb. I assume it’s as a result of there isn’t any respectable grazing for the animals. Having been used to salt marsh lamb within the UK we’ve been spoiled. Ibérico ham is gorgeous, however we will’t dwell on pork”.
Valerie concurred with Jane’s feedback, saying that “the provision of huge joints may be very restricted. The lamb joints are tiny plus the standard and style are poor. I don’t see any meat claiming to have good husbandry care, I believe most meat in Spain is mass produced”.
Chris Foster additionally thought equally when he stated: “I can’t discover natural meat regionally and the animal farms I’ve seen listed below are horrible. The meals they’re fed appears to be like horrible too”.
In the meantime, just a few respondents targeted on the style of the meat.
Thomas stated: “It tastes unusual, not like in different EU international locations. It’s very bizarre. I’m now largely vegetarian”.
Alan Robinson fully agreed “We discover it powerful and tasteless,” he stated. “It could be so significantly better in the event that they left some fats on it too”.
Roger merely thought that good high quality beef was very exhausting to search out, whereas Brian Wall thought that the majority forms of Spanish meat are unhealthy, however primarily as a result of manner it’s lower in Spain.
“The Spanish butchers don’t use or know the correct cuts of beef so their steaks are by no means what we count on. In consequence, steak is all the time disappointing for a Brit used to conventional sirloin or rump and many others. Moreover, the Spanish lamb is atrocious. I don’t know the place it comes from however it’s terrible and costly. Lastly, Spanish historically appear to favor wafer-thin chops and I’ve to remind the butcher to chop it thicker. My brother is a top-class chef and has hassle sourcing respectable meat,” he stated.
Then again, 1 / 4 of respondents stated that the standard of meat in Spain relies upon. Most agreed that good high quality meat is obtainable in Spain, however that is dependent upon the place you purchase it from, however others stated it relied on the kind of meat you purchase too.
John Latka defined: “It very a lot relies upon the place you buy your meat. I keep away from the supermarkets and purchase from a good butcher”.
Jonathan stated that “In fact there may be high-quality meat accessible in Spain, if you’re keen to pay for it…. most of what you see within the grocery store or served at a median restaurant is the sort of stuff that Garzón is speaking about. There’s a demand for affordable meat, and plenty of it, a requirement that these farms serve. The megafarms don’t make use of proportionally as many individuals, so for those who may persuade the inhabitants to scale back their meat consumption, however spend about the identical on a smaller amount of better-quality product, you may even enhance the financial system”.
Rob H agreed saying: “Usually talking, meat from conventional pastures is of excellent high quality. Spain produces meat in quite a lot of methods and it’s bought at quite a lot of costs. You get what you pay for. Personally, I attempt to purchase regionally produced meat that I do know doesn’t come from an enormous, industrially-run manufacturing facility farm. In order for you high quality you can purchase your meat at a butcher and ask the place it comes from. If worth is a precedence, because it understandably is for many individuals, it’s nonetheless attainable to purchase native meat, however by no means on the lowest worth”.
Anna additionally thought that it relied on the place the meat is sourced. “Animal merchandise produced on small farms utilizing conventional farming strategies is of wonderful high quality, each ethically, health-wise. Grocery store meat from mega-farms includes animal abuse and is harmful to devour,” she stated.
Susan Wallace stated: “I’ve purchased some wonderful high quality contemporary meat, particularly natural. And I believe bellota jamón merchandise are of very top quality, too. However “industrial” jamón is a distinct matter, and a few contemporary meat from supermarkets additionally leaves rather a lot to be desired”.
Matthew agreed with Susan, saying that the cured meats are wonderful, whereas contemporary meat right here is considerably much less, whereas Jerry B stated: “Beef is usually of very poor high quality (powerful, sinewy), whereas pork and hen are excellent”.